What’s Better for Car Insurance – GEICO or Progressive?

Last Updated on August 15, 2022

GEICO and Progressive are two of the most popular car insurance companies in the United States. Approximately 9% of American drivers are Progressive customers, while 11% are GEICO customers.

Which insurance company is better – GEICO or Progressive? Which company offers a better value on their car insurance policies? Which company handles claims more honestly and fairly? Which company works best for your unique needs? Today, we’re explaining everything you need to know about deciding between GEICO and Progressive.

Both GEICO and Progressive Are Extremely Competitive – So Don’t Expect Major Differences

The important thing to remember is that the big American insurance companies are extremely competitive with one another. When one company offers a unique product, another quickly matches it. GEICO and Progressive are two of the most popular insurance companies in the United States – so don’t expect to see major differences between the two.

Some drivers will have a better experience with GEICO. For example, you might have certain indicators that make you a less risky driver in the eyes of GEICO’s algorithm. Or, you might benefit from working with Progressive’s popular “Name Your Price” program – which could help some drivers save some money.

Ultimately, the best way to compare GEICO and Progressive is to get a quote from both insurance companies. Take a few minutes to fill out your basic information and receive a customized quote.

After getting a quote from both companies, then you’ll either reach two conclusions:

  • One company will offer a significantly lower price than the other
  • The two will offer fairly similar prices on fairly similar policies

If you requested a car insurance quote from both GEICO and Progressive and received a similar offer, then keep reading to find other differences between GEICO and Progressive.

J.D. Power Recently Ranked GEICO Higher than Progressive In All Categories

GEICO received a 4/5 on overall claims satisfaction, while Progressive received a 3/5 on overall claims satisfaction according to the 2019 J.D. Power rankings, which you can view here.

GEICO’s strong score in the recent J.D. Power rankings is a big deal. All other major insurance companies, including Allstate, Nationwide, State Farm, Esurance, Progressive, Travelers, MetLife, Farmers, and CSAA received an identical score of 3/5 in overall claims satisfaction. GEICO was the only major insurance company to receive a 4/5 score.

To put that score into perspective, the only insurance companies with a higher ranking than GEICO in 2017 were The Hanover, Hartford, Erie Insurance, Auto-Owners Insurance, and Amica Mutual. All of these insurance companies have a market share below 1.3%, while GEICO’s share sits at around 11%.

Here’s how GEICO and Progressive compared in other J.D. Power rankings criteria:

Overall Satisfaction4/53/5
First Notice of Loss (FNOL)4/53/5
Claim Servicing4/53/5
Estimation Process4/53/5
Repair Process3/53/5
Rental Experience4/54/5

As you can see, GEICO edges out Progressive in every category but two: repair process and rental experience. GEICO beats Progressive in 5 categories, while Progressive beats GEICO in 0 categories.

What about other ranking organizations and other criteria? How do GEICO and Progressive stack up outside of J.D. Power rankings? Keep reading to find out.

GEICO Versus Progressive: Other Comparisons


GEICO: All 50 states

Progressive: All 50 states

Good Driver Discounts

GEICO: Up to 26% discount; must have at least five years accident-free

Progressive: Up to 31% discount; must have no tickets or accidents within the last three years

Good Student Discounts

GEICO: 15% discount; must be a full-time student between 16-24 years with at least a 3.0 GPA to qualify

Progressive: Discount varies; must maintain at least a 3.0 GPA and be under 22 years of age; additional discounts are available if your school is 100+ miles away from home.

Telematics Discounts

GEICO: You can receive up to a 20% discount on your premiums with GEICO’s DriveEasy

Progressive: You can save an average of $145 annually by using Progressive’s Snapshot

Other Discounts

GEICO: Discounts for bundling with homeowner’s insurance, paying for insurance in full, being active duty or retired military (up to 15% discount), and being a federal employee (up to 8% discount).

Progressive: Discounts for bundling with home, renters, or condo insurance; discounts for bundling multiple car insurance policies, discounts for paying for insurance in full, and customized discounts through the “Name Your Price” tool

Vehicle Discounts

GEICO: Discounts for anti-theft devices, anti-lock brakes, and airbags

Progressive: Discounts for anti-theft devices, anti-lock brakes, and passive restraints

Remember: Car Insurance Companies Charge Different Rates in Different States

You might be a lifelong GEICO customer. You might be satisfied with your current insurance plan – but when you move to a new state, you find that you have other options available.

All major American car insurance companies – including GEICO and Progressive – are available in all 50 states. However, the plans and policies can vary widely between states – even within the same company. Drivers in certain states – like Florida, Michigan, and Louisiana – pay infamously high rates for car insurance whether they’re with GEICO or Progressive, for example.

On the other hand, certain insurance companies are known for offering especially cheap prices in certain states. Here are the states where Progressive and GEICO are comparatively cheap:

GEICO: Cheapest in Alaska, Maine, and Vermont

Progressive: Cheapest in Alabama, Iowa, and Idaho

Final Word – Which Is Better GEICO or Progressive?

Overall, the most important thing to remember is to compare auto insurance quotes to find the best insurance company for your unique needs. GEICO will offer the best plans for certain drivers, while Progressive will offer superior plans to other drivers.

Start comparing car insurance today to decide whether Progressive or GEICO is the right choice for you.

James Shaffer
James Shaffer James Shaffer is a writer for InsurancePanda.com and a well-seasoned auto insurance industry veteran. He has a deep knowledge of insurance rules and regulations and is passionate about helping drivers save money on auto insurance. He is responsible for researching and writing about anything auto insurance-related. He holds a bachelor's degree from Bentley University and his work has been quoted by NBC News, CNN, and The Washington Post.
Back to Top