What’s Better for Car Insurance – Farmers or State Farm?
Last Updated on October 18, 2026
Farmers and State Farm are two leading insurance companies with nationwide name recognition, lots of policy options, and local agent support. If you’re comparing them, you’re already looking at two reputable insurers—so the “better” choice usually comes down to pricing in your ZIP code, how you prefer to manage your policy, and which company’s discounts and add-ons fit your situation.
Below is a practical, updated comparison to help you pick between Farmers and State Farm for car insurance—and know what to ask for when you get quotes.
- Neither Farmers nor State Farm is “always cheaper”—the better deal depends on your ZIP code, driving record, vehicle, and discount eligibility.
- State Farm has about 19,000 agents, a discount list that includes Drive Safe & Save and a good student discount of up to 25%, and an AM Best rating of A+ (Superior) since a November 2025 downgrade from A++.
- Farmers sells a longer menu of optional coverages (OEM parts, new car replacement, rideshare, custom equipment) and carries an AM Best rating of A (Excellent), affirmed September 3, 2026. Neither company publishes average prices, so neither can be called the cheaper one in general.
- To choose confidently, compare quotes with identical coverages and ask each insurer about telematics and bundling opportunities.
- Farmers vs. State Farm: quick comparison
- About Farmers
- About State Farm
- Which is cheaper: Farmers or State Farm?
- Discounts and savings opportunities
- Telematics: Farmers Signal vs. State Farm Drive Safe & Save
- Coverage options and add-ons
- Financial strength: Farmers vs. State Farm
- Customer service and claims experience
- So, what’s better for car insurance: Farmers or State Farm?
- How to get the best quote (no matter which company you pick)
- FAQs on Farmers vs. State Farm Car Insurance
- Sources
Farmers vs. State Farm: quick comparison
| Category | Farmers | State Farm | Who it may fit best |
|---|---|---|---|
| Price | Filed state by state; no published average | Filed state by state; no published average | Nobody can say which is cheaper for you without two matching quotes |
| Agent experience | Strong local agent model | Very large agent footprint and high brand consistency | If you want a long-term agent relationship, both can work well |
| Policy customization | Lots of add-ons and packages | Solid add-ons plus broad discount menu | Drivers who want “extras” may lean Farmers; compare the discounts each company actually applies to your quote |
| Telematics app | Signal (discount for enrolling; riskier driving could raise your premium at renewal; not offered in FL, HI or NY) | Drive Safe & Save (10% to start, up to 30%; premium may increase or decrease at renewal; not offered in CA, MA or RI) | Phone-free, smooth drivers who want to earn discounts |
| Best way to choose | Run identical coverage quotes (same limits/deductibles) and compare the final price after discounts and add-ons | ||
About Farmers
Farmers dates to 1928, and its policies are written by three reciprocal exchanges owned by their policyholders (Farmers Insurance Exchange, Fire Insurance Exchange and Truck Insurance Exchange). It is best known for selling through local agents and offering a wide menu of optional coverages. In addition to auto insurance, Farmers also sells home, renters, umbrella, business, and life insurance products, plus add-ons like roadside assistance. If you like the idea of building a policy with lots of “extras,” Farmers is often appealing.
About State Farm
State Farm is the largest personal lines insurer in the U.S. by premiums written, according to AM Best, and its own site says it has about 19,000 agents. Alongside auto insurance, State Farm also offers home, renters, life, and financial products—and many customers use State Farm to bundle policies for additional savings. You can also add services like roadside assistance depending on your state and policy.
Which is cheaper: Farmers or State Farm?
There’s no universal winner because rates are driven by your location and profile. Neither company publishes its average premiums, and the comparison sites that print carrier averages each use their own sample driver and disagree with one another, so we won’t tell you one is cheaper. Rates are filed state by state, and the only number that counts is the one on your two quotes.
The most common reasons one company beats the other are:
- Your driving record: Even one moving violation (like speeding tickets) can change which company is cheaper. Major violations like DUIs usually cause big differences in pricing between carriers.
- Age and household makeup: A teen driver, a newly licensed driver, or multiple drivers on one policy can swing the quote dramatically.
- Discount match: One company might “fit” your life better (bundle discounts, student discounts, good-driver programs, etc.).
- Vehicle and coverage choices: Your car, safety features, and coverage limits/deductibles can push quotes in either direction.
Bottom line: don’t compare “company reputations.” Compare two real quotes with the exact same coverage.
Discounts and savings opportunities
Both companies offer plenty of discounts, but they’re structured a bit differently:
Farmers discounts
Farmers’ discounts page lists a homeowner discount, a mature driver discount for drivers over 55 who complete state-approved training, bundling (Farmers says 10% or more for home and auto), good student and distant student discounts, a five-year accident-free discount, and Farmers GroupSelect pricing through participating employers and associations. If you want the full list to ask an agent about, start here: Farmers discounts.
State Farm discounts
State Farm’s discounts page lists bundling with home, renters, condo or life policies, Drive Safe & Save (up to 30%), a good student discount of up to 25% that can last until the student turns 25, the Steer Clear program for drivers under 25, a good driver discount for new customers with three or more clean years, and a passive restraint discount of up to 40% on medical-related coverages. For the most useful discounts to request upfront, see: State Farm discounts.
Telematics: Farmers Signal vs. State Farm Drive Safe & Save
If you’re comfortable with an app tracking driving behavior, telematics can be one of the biggest “difference-makers” between carriers.
Farmers Signal
Farmers Signal is a smartphone program that tracks driving behaviors like phone use and hard braking. It may lead to renewal savings for safer driving—but Farmers also notes that riskier driving behavior could increase your premium at renewal in participating situations. Farmers’ Signal page says the program and its discount are not available in Florida, Hawaii or New York, that the discount is not available in California, and that it is limited to certain policy types; Farmers’ main auto page also lists South Carolina as excluded, so ask your agent which list applies to you. Confirm availability and how your renewal is affected before you enroll.
State Farm Drive Safe & Save
Drive Safe & Save collects driving information through the State Farm app and a Bluetooth beacon State Farm mails you, scoring acceleration, braking, cornering, speed (8 mph or more over the limit), phone distraction and mileage. State Farm’s page says you get a 10% decrease for signing up and could save up to 30%, but it also says your premium “may increase or decrease at each renewal,” so this is not a discount-only program. It is not offered in California, Massachusetts or Rhode Island and may not be available in North Carolina.
Coverage options and add-ons
Both insurers offer the standard foundations (liability, collision, comprehensive, medical payments/PIP where available, uninsured/underinsured motorist). The differences show up in optional coverages and how easy it is to tailor a policy to your needs. If you want a refresher on the building blocks, see auto insurance types.
Farmers is often a strong choice if you want “customization” options, such as:
- New car replacement coverage (helpful for newer vehicles)
- Rental reimbursement coverage (so you’re not stuck without a car during repairs)
- OEM parts coverage (for drivers who prefer original parts after certain repairs)
State Farm offers many add-ons too, and it can be especially attractive if you need rideshare protection. If you drive for Uber or Lyft, review the rideshare gap carefully and consider insurers that specifically support that use case, including options for Uber and Lyft drivers.
On Farmers’ coverage page, the OEM parts option is for cars up to 10 years old, rental reimbursement runs up to 30 days, and new car replacement (Farmers also calls it Vehicle Replacement Plus) varies by state. Farmers also lists customized equipment coverage, gap coverage, rideshare and food delivery coverage, and accident forgiveness that forgives one at-fault accident for every three years you drive without one (not offered in CA, HI, NC, NY or SC). State Farm’s coverage options page lists emergency road service, car rental and travel expenses, and rideshare coverage that extends your existing limits and deductibles while you are on the app; it does not list new car replacement, OEM parts or gap coverage.
Financial strength: Farmers vs. State Farm
Financial strength ratings matter because they’re meant to reflect an insurer’s ability to pay claims even during tough years (high catastrophe losses, inflation in repair costs, etc.). AM Best rates the Farmers Insurance Group members (Farmers Insurance Exchange, Fire Insurance Exchange, Truck Insurance Exchange and their affiliates, a pooled group rating) A (Excellent) with a stable outlook, affirmed September 3, 2026, when it also raised the outlook on their issuer credit ratings to positive. On November 14, 2025, AM Best lowered State Farm Mutual Automobile Insurance Company and its affiliates to A+ (Superior) from A++ (Superior), with a stable outlook, citing five straight years of underwriting losses in auto and homeowners; A+ is still AM Best’s second-highest grade. Policies are written by a specific legal company, so check the company named on your declarations page. Ratings change, so look again at renewal. If you want to learn how to interpret these ratings, see how to evaluate an insurance company’s financial stability.
Customer service and claims experience
Both Farmers and State Farm sell primarily through agents, which can be a huge advantage if you prefer talking to a human when something goes wrong. If you’re not sure which channel you want, it helps to understand the difference between an insurance broker and an agent.
J.D. Power’s 2026 U.S. Auto Insurance Study (June 9, 2026) ranks insurers by region on a 1,000-point scale. State Farm ranked highest in the Northwest region with 667 points; Farmers did not rank highest in any of the 11 regions. Both companies’ scores in the other regions sit in J.D. Power’s regional tables, so look up your own region rather than reading a national verdict into one result.
When you evaluate service, pay attention to:
- Agent responsiveness (calls returned, policy changes handled correctly)
- Claims communication (updates, timelines, repair coordination)
- Repair options (shop network, parts policies, rental coordination)
No matter who you choose, it helps to know the proper way to file an insurance claim, because good documentation and the right sequence of steps can prevent delays and confusion.
So, what’s better for car insurance: Farmers or State Farm?
Choose State Farm if its quote comes in lower, you want the larger agent network, and the discounts it lists (good student, bundling, Drive Safe & Save) apply to you.
Choose Farmers if you want a highly customizable policy with strong add-on options and you’re comfortable working closely with an agent to build coverage that matches your needs—with the add-ons you want priced into the quote you compare.
How to get the best quote (no matter which company you pick)
- Quote both companies with identical coverage. Same limits, same deductibles, same drivers, same vehicles.
- Be honest about your driving history. Even one incident can move the needle: your driving history is one of the biggest pricing factors.
- Consider how your car impacts your premium. Some vehicles are simply more expensive to insure: your type of car can dramatically change the quote.
- Ask about telematics and bundling. If you can earn a meaningful discount safely, it’s often one of the biggest savings levers.
If you’re stuck choosing, the simplest rule is this: pick the company that gives you the best total price for the coverage you actually want—and that you’ll feel comfortable dealing with during a claim.
My advice is to ask each agent for a quote with the exact same limits and deductibles, then have State Farm show the Drive Safe & Save and good student discounts on paper and have Farmers price the OEM parts and new car replacement options as separate lines. The company that wins on that sheet is your answer, and it may flip at your next renewal.
FAQs on Farmers vs. State Farm Car Insurance
Sources
Checked October 18, 2026
- Farmers — About Farmers
- Farmers — Car Insurance
- Farmers — Car Insurance Coverage
- Farmers — Car Insurance Discounts
- Farmers — Signal
- State Farm — About Us
- State Farm — Car Insurance Coverage Options
- State Farm — Car Insurance Discounts
- State Farm — Drive Safe & Save
- AM Best — Rating Action on Farmers Insurance Group Members, September 3, 2026
- AM Best — Rating Action on State Farm Group, November 14, 2025
- J.D. Power — 2026 U.S. Auto Insurance Study, June 9, 2026
