Should Seniors Get AARP’s Auto Insurance?

Last Updated on December 9, 2022

You’ve heard of AARP and its auto insurance program, but is it right for you to try it out?

AARP stands for the American Association of Retired Persons. It’s essentially a membership club that’s geared toward the elderly. In many ways, it’s similar to groups like the VA, or even programs such as rewards credit cards.

AARP auto insurance for seniorsWhile AARP is focused on people in their 50s, 60s, 70s, and older, technically, there is no age requirement to join. As long as you pay the $16 fee, you can gain access to AARP’s large range of discount programs, travel deals, and services.

Just being a senior citizen gets you many discounts at restaurants, movie theaters, and other places. However, through AARP, everything is in one place with one card and membership guide. This can be convenient when trying to remember what you qualify for.

There are many resources that discuss the full range of benefits offered by AARP, but this article will focus more on the auto insurance program.

AARP’s Auto Insurance Program

AARP does not directly offer auto insurance. It is not an insurance company. The insurance part is offered through The Hartford, one of the largest insurance companies in the nation. AARP has partnered with them to offer a discounted program for its members.

This is a natural fit because The Hartford has traditionally been competitive with older drivers and thrives in that market, whether they are AARP members already or not.

The Hartford’s insurance program through AARP includes perks such as:

  • Disappearing Deductibles: If you maintain a claims-free record, your deductibles will lower automatically at no additional charge each year. It will lower to $0.
  • Accident Forgiveness: If you qualify, then The Hartford won’t raise your rates after your first accident. You must have a clean record for five years to qualify for free first accident forgiveness.
  • Roadside Assistance: AARP offers 24-hour roadside assistance coverage. It offers all the usual roadside assistance perks, including towing, fuel delivery, battery jumpstarts, emergency locksmith services, winching/extraction services, and tire changes.
  • New Car Replacement Coverage: If you total your new car within a certain number of miles of driving it, AARP/The Hartford will replace it with a new one of the same make and model.
  • Waiver of Deductible: If the accident isn’t your fault, The Hartford won’t charge you a collision deductible.

These extra perks are not offered in every state and are only available to drivers with no accidents or violations in the last five years.

When you get insurance coverage through AARP and The Hartford, you will automatically be enrolled in their “Advantage” program, which is their base auto insurance coverage offering. For additional coverage and more features, you can update to the “Advantage Plus” program. The table below compares the coverage offered by the Advantage and Advantage Plus programs:

Auto Insurance FeaturesAdvantageAdvantage Plus
24-Hour Roadside AssistanceYesYes
24x7 Claim Reporting ServiceYesYes
$100 Collision Deductible ReductionNoYes
Accident ForgivenessNoYes
Annual Policy TermYesYes
Auto & Home Account Policy SavingsYesYes
Collision Deductible WaiverNoYes
Countrywide Claims ServiceYesYes
Customer Repair Service Program (CRSP) with Life of Vehicle GuaranteeYesYes
Disappearing DeductibleNoYes
Emergency Expense CoverageNoYes
Full Range of Coverage LimitsYesYes
Full Range of Deductible OptionsYesYes
Home Ownership CreditYesYes
Hybrid Vehicle DiscountYesYes
Legal Representation for AccidentsYesYes
New Car Replacement CoverageYesYes
New Vehicle DiscountYesYes
No Deductible Windshield Repair ServiceYesYes
Non-Resident Student DiscountYesYes
One DeductibleNoYes
Paid In Full or Monthly EFTYesYes
Personal Umbrella DiscountYesYes
RecoverCare Essential ServicesYesYes

To learn more about these perks, please call your AARP or The Hartford agent.

A nice perk of AARP’s association with The Hartford is that they will guarantee to renew your policy every year, as long as you:

They aren’t guaranteeing that they will be the cheapest auto insurance company for seniors, but at least you can maintain a policy with them for as long as you need to.

One important thing to keep in mind is your other insurance policies. If you have a homeowner’s or a renter’s policy with one company, and you switch to AARP’s insurance program with The Hartford, you will lose any multi-policy discount you used to have.

The multi-policy discount is usually around 15%, so losing that can have a big impact on your premiums.

The Hartford does offer a homeowners insurance discount through AARP, so you could quote your home or renters policy through them to keep the multi-policy discount. Unfortunately, for many retirees, this homeowner’s product is not offered in Florida.

The Final Verdict on AARP Auto Insurance

AARP’s auto insurance discount through The Hartford likely won’t be the least expensive auto insurance available. It might be inexpensive, and you might save money by switching, but there always seems to be a company that offers lower rates (sometimes at the expense of service and/or coverages).

It’s not recommended to switch to AARP’s auto insurance program solely to save money. However, if the wide range of additional benefits is a good fit for you and your lifestyle, it’s certainly worth checking out.

Also, you aren’t forced into joining AARP’s auto insurance program. So, you can become an AARP member and enjoy the full range of benefits while staying with your current auto insurance carrier.

With that in mind, it is worth it to at least have The Hartford quote your auto insurance if you join AARP. You don’t have to join, and they might be able to save you money and/or improve your current coverage.

Andrew Flueckiger
Andrew Flueckiger Andrew Flueckiger is an experienced insurance agent with experience in sales, management, leadership, and marketing. A graduate of Indiana University, Andrew is a licensed insurance agent specializing in personal and commercial insurance. Andrew not only holds a wealth of insurance industry knowledge and expertise, in 2016, he also obtained the Certified Insurance Counselor designation.
Back to Top