How to Find Cheap Auto Insurance Quotes Even If You Have a Speeding Ticket
Last Updated on October 14, 2026
So you received a speeding ticket—but you still want to find cheap auto insurance. While a ticket usually raises your rates, there are still reliable ways to secure affordable coverage. Below, we break down how speeding tickets affect insurance and how you can still get cheap quotes afterward.
- Speeding Tickets Affect Rates Differently by Insurer: Some companies raise your rates immediately after one ticket, while others forgive the first one—especially if you have an otherwise clean record.
- You May Lose Safe Driving Discounts: Many insurers reward clean driving. A speeding ticket may cause these discounts to disappear, resulting in a higher premium even without a surcharge.
- Tickets Can Affect Your Rate for About 3 Years: Many insurers look back about three years when rating violations, and some look back further. Even if points drop off early, the ticket may remain visible in your motor vehicle report.
- You Can Still Get Cheap Rates: Comparing multiple insurers, maintaining a clean record afterward, trading in for a safer vehicle, and reassessing optional coverages can all help reduce your premiums.
How Do Speeding Tickets Affect Insurance Rates?
Your driving record is one of the biggest factors insurers use to set your premiums. A speeding ticket signals risk, so insurers may increase your rate at your next renewal.
Some insurers impose a surcharge immediately after your first ticket. Others may forgive one violation—especially if you’ve been a long-term safe driver. Younger drivers and those with multiple infractions often see the biggest increases.
Your insurer may also look more harshly on multiple violations in a short period, even if your record was clean for years beforehand.
How much a ticket adds depends on the insurer, your state and your profile. LendingTree’s speeding-ticket study, using late-2025 rates from Quadrant Information Services, found a first speeding ticket (11 to 15 mph over) raised full-coverage premiums by 22.7% on average, about $525 a year, for a 30-year-old man with good credit driving a 2018 Honda CR-V. Your own increase can be higher or lower, so get quotes rather than relying on an average.
Regardless of age, drivers with repeat violations are far more likely to face higher premiums or be placed in a higher-risk tier. Maintaining a clean record after receiving a ticket is essential for lowering your rates again.
You Could Lose Safe Driving Bonuses
Many insurers offer good driver discounts to policyholders who avoid violations. A speeding ticket may remove these discounts instantly—even if your base rate doesn’t change yet.
Losing a safe-driver discount can sometimes hurt more than the ticket surcharge itself. Here’s a look at common good-driver discounts:
| Insurer | Discounts |
|---|---|
| Allstate | * Drivewise – Allstate’s discounts page says you get savings for enrolling and more for good driving. * Other good-driver discounts – We could not confirm a Safe Driving Bonus percentage or any Premier discounts from anything Allstate publishes nationally, so ask an agent what applies in your state. |
| American Family | * Good Driving – American Family says drivers without accidents, violations or claims may be eligible for a reduced rate; it does not list a percentage. * DriveMyWay – American Family says you could save 10% to 35% based on your driving habits. |
| Esurance | * Allstate announced in December 2019 that it would phase out the Esurance brand, and many Esurance coverage and discount pages now point to Allstate. If you have or are quoting an Esurance policy, ask which good-driver discounts apply. |
| GEICO | * Good Driver Discount – GEICO says a driver accident-free for at least one year may save up to 22% on most coverages, depending on the state. * Defensive Driver Course – Additional state-dependent savings. |
| Nationwide | * Accident-Free Discount – Nationwide offers a discount for keeping an accident-free record; its discounts page gives no percentage. * SmartRide – An instant 10% when you enroll; the ongoing discount depends on how you drive. |
| MetLife | * Farmers completed its purchase of MetLife’s auto and home business on April 7, 2021. We could not confirm the old Super Driver or MetRewards discounts from anything Farmers publishes today, so ask your agent which good-driver discounts apply. |
| Progressive | * Safe Driver Discount – Progressive says safe drivers pay an average of 33% less for coverage bought directly from Progressive. * Snapshot – Progressive lists average savings of $328 on its discounts page (October 2026); not available in California. |
| State Farm | * Good Driving Discount – For new State Farm Mutual customers with 3 years or more without moving violations or at-fault accidents; State Farm does not list a percentage. * Drive Safe & Save – An initial discount for enrolling, then up to 30% based on how you drive (varies by state). |
| Travelers | * Safe Driver Discount – For households with no accidents, violations or major comprehensive claims over the past three to five years; Travelers’ discounts page gives no percentage. * IntelliDrive – Can reward safer driving with savings; ask Travelers for the amount in your state. |
How Long Do Speeding Tickets Stay on Your Record?
Many insurers look back about three years when they rate tickets, and some look back further. That lookback runs separately from your state’s point system, so a ticket can still show up on a quote after its points stop counting toward a suspension.
How long a ticket stays on your driving record is set by your state, and the rules differ a lot. In New York, for example, the DMV says points stop counting toward your total 24 months after the violation date, while the conviction itself stays on your record longer. Check your own state DMV’s driver record page for the rule where you live.
My advice is to get at least three quotes at your first renewal after the ticket, with the same limits and deductibles, and ask each company whether it forgives a first minor ticket. Then put a reminder on your calendar for three years out and shop again once the ticket ages off.
FAQs
Final Word
The best way to get cheaper insurance after a speeding ticket is to compare quotes from multiple insurers. Companies weigh violations differently; some may overlook your first ticket, while others may treat you as high-risk immediately.
Another strategy is simple: wait. Tickets become less influential the older they get. Once the ticket ages past your insurer’s lookback period, often about three years, and you have no new violations, your rate is likely to come down, though other rating changes can still move it.
Additional ways to save include:
- Compare quotes from multiple insurers
- Stay ticket-free for at least three years
- Drive a safer vehicle with better crash ratings (see the IIHS vehicle ratings)
- Remove optional coverages if financially appropriate
At the end of the day, insurers evaluate risk—and your driving history is one of the strongest risk indicators. A driver with multiple speeding tickets will usually appear to be a higher-risk customer than someone with no violations.
Sources
Checked October 13, 2026
- LendingTree — Across US, Speeding Tickets Drive Up Insurance Costs by Over $500 a Year
- Progressive — Car Insurance Discounts
- State Farm — Car Insurance Discounts
- American Family Insurance — Car Insurance Discounts
- Nationwide — Auto Insurance Discounts
- New York State DMV — About the NYS Driver Point System
