Is Infinity Auto Insurance Good?

Last Updated on October 19, 2026

Infinity is no longer a name Kemper sells under. It survives as an underwriting company name that still turns up on policies, while infinityauto.com quotes more than one carrier as an agency. Whether a policy bought that way is a good fit depends on the coverage you choose, your driving history, and which company ends up writing it.

Below is what Infinity is, what it typically offers, and what to check before you buy a policy.

Infinity at a Glance

Infinity is a legacy underwriting name inside Kemper’s company structure rather than a brand Kemper markets, and infinityauto.com now operates as an agency marketplace with access to multiple carriers.

Quick facts

Type: a legacy Kemper underwriting name; Kemper sells this business as Kemper Auto in 22 states

On policies: nine Infinity-named companies remain on Kemper’s list of underwriting companies

infinityauto.com: now an independent agency with access to more than 20 carriers

Who writes your policy: check the company name on your declarations page

Our score: see our Kemper review; Infinity policies written by Kemper companies are rated there

Summary

Bottom line: Treat Infinity as a name on paperwork and check who is actually underwriting the policy. A quote through infinityauto.com may be written by a Kemper company, an Infinity-named Kemper company, or a carrier with neither name on it.

Infinity is not a brand Kemper sells under any more. Kemper’s 2025 annual report says the specialty segment writes in 22 states under the Kemper Auto brand and never uses the Infinity name, and no page on kemper.com uses it either. What survives is the underwriting paperwork: nine Infinity-named companies are still on Kemper’s published list of underwriting companies, so Infinity can be the company printed on a policy. Separately, infinityauto.com now runs as an insurance agency and says it has access to more than 20 carriers, so a quote from that site may be written by a company with no Infinity or Kemper name on it. Coverage follows a familiar menu, from basic liability to full coverage with common add-ons.

Best for

  • Drivers who want straightforward coverage choices and payment flexibility
  • People who may not qualify for preferred-market pricing due to driving history
  • Shoppers comfortable comparing matched quotes and reading policy details closely

Not ideal for

  • Drivers who want a premium, high-touch service experience
  • Shoppers who expect identical features and digital tools in every state
  • People who prefer a “preferred carrier” approach with broad perks and enhancements

What Is Infinity Insurance?

Infinity Property and Casualty Corporation was a Birmingham, Alabama company that traded on Nasdaq as IPCC until Kemper bought it in a deal that closed in July 2018. It described itself then as a national auto insurer concentrating on nonstandard insurance, which is still the market this business serves: drivers who pay more because of tickets, accidents, lapses or limited insurance history.

Infinity is part of Kemper, a national insurance group headquartered on East Randolph Street in Chicago. Here is the part worth knowing before you shop: Kemper no longer markets this business under the Infinity name. Kemper’s 2025 annual report says the specialty segment “conducts business in 22 states under the Kemper Auto brand,” and the Infinity name appears nowhere in that filing, and no page on kemper.com uses it. What did not change is the paperwork. Kemper’s own list of underwriting companies still shows nine Infinity carriers in use, including Infinity Insurance Company, Infinity Auto Insurance Company and Infinity County Mutual Insurance Company.

The website is a different thing again. infinityauto.com now runs as Infinity Insurance Agency, Inc., an agency that says it has access to more than 20 carriers and sells personal and commercial auto, with Spanish-language service. In California it does business as Infinity General Insurance Agency. So a quote from that site may well be written by a company with no Infinity or Kemper name on it at all.

Infinity Insurance Contact Information
Mailing Address900 East Laurel Ave, Suite 100, McAllen, TX 78501 (the agency’s address). For anything about an existing policy, use the address on your declarations page or billing statement.
Phone NumberCustomer service 1-800-690-3818, Monday to Friday 8 a.m. to 6 p.m. local time and Saturday 8:30 a.m. to 3 p.m. Quotes 1-855-478-3705, Monday to Friday 8 a.m. to 10 p.m. Central and Saturday 8 a.m. to 5 p.m.
EmailNone published. Neither the Infinity site nor Kemper publishes a customer service email address, so use the phone lines or the contact details on your policy documents.
Websiteinfinityauto.com, now run as Infinity Insurance Agency, Inc.

Infinity Insurance Products & Services

Infinity is primarily recognized for auto insurance, but availability of additional lines can vary by state. Here’s how its core offerings are commonly positioned:

ProductWhat It’s ForWhat to Verify
Auto InsuranceBasic liability coverage up to full coverage, plus optional add-onsWhether the quote is issued by an Infinity/Kemper carrier entity or placed through an affiliated agency, and what optional coverages are available in your state
Business InsuranceCoverage for business vehicles and liability needsWhether you need a true commercial policy (see: commercial auto insurance) and what vehicle types are eligible
PropertyKemper has no homeowners policy. Its property product is fire and contents protection insuranceWhether it is sold in your state, what it excludes, and that it is not a substitute for a homeowners policy

Roadside assistance is an optional coverage rather than a separate program. Kemper Auto describes it as 24/7 towing, jump-starts, fuel delivery, lockout help and tire changes, but publishes no towing mileage or dollar limit, so ask for those before you add it (see: roadside assistance program).

How Does Infinity Auto Insurance Work?

Infinity auto insurance works like most standard car insurance: you choose liability limits to meet your state’s requirements and add optional coverages to protect your own vehicle. The biggest decision is usually whether you’re buying minimum liability coverage or a broader package like full coverage car insurance.

Common coverage options include:

Coverage TypeWhat It CoversWhy It Matters
LiabilityInjuries and property damage you cause to others (see: liability coverage)Required in most states; higher limits help protect your assets
Bodily Injury LiabilityMedical costs and related damages for others if you cause a crashOften the most financially important limit on your policy (see: bodily injury)
Property Damage LiabilityRepairs for the other driver’s car (and other property) if you’re at faultImportant if you drive in areas with newer/expensive vehicles (see: property damage liability coverage)
ComprehensiveTheft, vandalism, weather, animal hits, glass damage, and moreHelps protect your car outside of crashes (see: comprehensive)
CollisionRepairs for your vehicle after a crash (subject to deductible)Commonly required if you finance or lease (see: collision coverage)
Uninsured / Underinsured MotoristProtection if you’re hit by a driver with no insurance or too little insuranceEspecially useful in higher-uninsured-driving areas (see: uninsured and underinsured motorist coverage)
Rideshare CoverageKemper Auto’s coverage page does not list rideshare coverage or a rideshare endorsementPersonal policies often have exclusions without the right endorsement (see: Uber and Lyft drivers)
Classic / Collector VehicleKemper Auto does not list classic car coverage; Kemper does write motorcycle, ATV, RV, boat and snowmobileNot all insurers write this; always confirm eligibility and usage rules (see: classic car insurance)

Kemper Auto’s coverage page also names personal injury protection in no-fault states, rental car reimbursement while your car is being repaired, and roadside assistance. Those three are worth asking about by name, since they are easy to leave off a cheap quote.

Infinity also offers coverage for some business vehicles. If the vehicle is titled to a business or used primarily for business purposes, the correct solution is usually a commercial policy instead of a personal policy with add-ons.

What Makes Infinity Auto Insurance Unique?

Infinity doesn’t compete by trying to be “everything for everyone.” It’s generally positioned as a practical option for drivers who want coverage that meets legal and lender requirements—especially those who may not qualify for the lowest rates with preferred carriers.

FeatureWhat It MeansWhat to Ask Before Buying
Kemper-Backed BrandNine Infinity carriers are still on Kemper’s published list of underwriting companies, even though Kemper markets the business as Kemper AutoWhich company is underwriting your policy and who will handle your claim (see: some of its larger competitors)
Roadside Assistance OptionsAn optional coverage: 24/7 towing, jump-start, fuel delivery, lockout and tire changeIs roadside assistance included, optional, or pay-per-use—and what towing limits apply
Digital ToolsMany insurers now offer apps for ID cards, billing, and claims updatesWhether your policy supports digital ID cards, text/email claim updates, and online payments in your state

Quick tip: When comparing Infinity to other insurers, match the quote to the same liability limits and deductibles. A cheaper quote often comes from lower limits or a higher deductible—not necessarily better pricing.

Infinity Auto Insurance Discounts

Kemper Auto publishes its discount list and puts no percentages on it, so there is nothing to compare on paper. Confirm what applies to your exact quote and what proof is required. The table below marks which discounts are on Kemper Auto’s own list as of October 4, 2026.

DiscountTypical QualificationRelated DetailsOn Kemper Auto’s list?
Multi-VehicleInsuring more than one car on the same policyUseful for households with multiple drivers (see: insure multiple vehicles)Yes, as the multi-car discount
Safe DriverFewer accidents/violations over a set periodOften tied to your motor vehicle report (see: safe driving discount)No
Clean RecordNo recent major violations or at-fault accidentsRules vary by carrier and state (see: drivers with a clean record)No
Paid-in-FullPaying the policy term upfront instead of monthlyMay reduce service fees (see: in full upfront)Yes
Good StudentStudents meeting GPA/academic requirements (where offered)Eligibility and proof requirements vary (see: meets certain grade requirements)Yes, for a full-time student with a 3.0 GPA or higher
HomeownerOwning a home (even without bundling, in some cases)Not available everywhere (see: if you own your own home)Yes, when the homeowners policy address matches the auto policy address
Vehicle Safety FeaturesFactory-installed safety tech and anti-theft devicesDiscounts may depend on VIN verification (see: safety features)No
AAA MemberActive AAA membership (where offered)May require verification (see: AAA members)No
Kemper Co-PilotSharing your driving habits through Kemper’s mobile appA telematics discount; the app has its own termsYes
Advance QuoteGetting your quote before your current policy expiresAsk how many days ahead you need to quoteYes
Proof of Prior InsuranceShowing you were already insuredWorth asking about if you have no lapse; have your old declarations page readyYes
Defensive Driving CourseCompleting an approved safe driving courseRules and accepted courses vary by state (see: defensive driving course discounts)Yes

Infinity Insurance Reviews & Ratings: What Do Customers Have to Say?

Online feedback on specialty insurers runs hot in both directions, and it is hard to weigh. The BBB files are easier to read. The Infinity Insurance profile in Birmingham is marked Not Rated, is not a BBB accredited business, and shows no complaints on file; BBB notes that complaints against it are handled by the Greater Atlanta BBB. The Kemper Corporation profile in Chicago carries an A+ rating and BBB accreditation, with 384 complaints in the last three years and 109 closed in the last 12 months. Both were read on October 4, 2026. Neither profile shows a BBB alert.

Complaint counts like that are normal for a group this size and are not a finding of wrongdoing. No regulator or court has found that Infinity or Kemper runs a scam, and nothing here says otherwise. What the counts are good for is reading the complaint texts to see which problems keep coming up.

When evaluating Infinity, focus on these practical checkpoints:

  • Claims accessibility: How do you file a claim, and what is the expected timeline for an adjuster contact?
  • Payment flexibility: Are there installment fees, and what happens if you pay late?
  • Repair process: Do they require estimates from certain shops or use preferred networks?
  • Policy clarity: Are exclusions and deductibles explained clearly on the declarations page?

Final Word on Infinity Auto Insurance

Buying through the Infinity site can make sense if you need straightforward coverage and don’t qualify for the lowest rates with preferred insurers. Just remember you are shopping through an agency, so read the policy documents carefully, see which company is named on them, confirm the billing rules, and find out how that company handles claims in your state.

If you’re comparing Infinity to other insurers, pull at least a few quotes with the same limits and deductibles, then choose the option that balances price, coverage, and service expectations. My advice is to ask which company is going to issue the policy before you hand over a card, because with this group the answer can be an Infinity carrier, a Kemper carrier, or something else entirely if you quoted through the agency site. For Kemper-related contact details and support channels, see Kemper customer service contact number.

FAQs on Infinity Auto Insurance

Sources

Checked October 4, 2026