Does the Color of Your Car Affect Your Insurance Rates?

Last Updated on October 15, 2026

“Red cars cost more to insure.” It’s one of the most persistent car insurance myths—right up there with other popular car insurance myths.

Here’s the truth: in nearly all cases, the color of your car does not affect your insurance rates. Insurers care about risk (crashes, theft, repair costs), and paint color usually isn’t part of that pricing equation.

  • In most cases, your car’s paint color (red, black, white, etc.) does not affect your auto insurance premium.
  • Insurers mainly price policies using your vehicle’s VIN-based details (make/model/trim), repair costs, location, mileage, coverage choices, and your driving record.
  • The “red cars cost more” myth often comes from confusing color with higher-risk vehicle types (sports cars, convertibles, luxury models) and driver behavior.
  • Custom paint or wraps usually won’t raise your base rate, but they can affect how much a claim costs—so ask about custom parts/equipment coverage if you’ve upgraded your car.

Quick Answer: No—Car Color Typically Doesn’t Affect Insurance Premiums

If you’ve ever wondered why your rates changed after switching vehicles or renewing a policy, it’s far more likely due to normal pricing factors—not paint. (If you’re dealing with a surprise increase, see why your car insurance company raised your rates.)

Auto insurers usually price your policy using factors like:

Notice what’s missing: the color of the car. Even if you’re paying “too much” and it feels random, it’s usually tied to rating details—not paint. (Related: why insurance can be high with no accidents.)

Why Insurers Don’t Price Policies Based on Paint Color

Insurers identify and price vehicles using the VIN (vehicle identification number), which tells them what matters for risk and cost—like the exact model, engine, safety tech, and typical repair expenses.

Some insurers ask for color to help identify the vehicle in a theft or claim, and some don’t ask at all; Progressive says it won’t even ask about it. Either way, color is not a pricing variable.

So Why Does the “Red Car Costs More” Myth Exist?

No one can pinpoint a single origin story, but a few ideas keep the myth alive.

1) Some safety research links visibility and crash risk to certain colors

The best-known study, a 2007 report from Australia’s Monash University Accident Research Centre, found that several colors, black and grey among them, had a higher crash risk than white, mostly in daylight, which points to visibility and contrast. That’s not the same as saying “red is expensive to insure,” and it doesn’t mean insurers rate your policy by paint color—but it helps explain why the topic gets attention.

2) Color gets blamed for what’s really a vehicle-type issue

“Flashy colors” tend to show up more often on vehicles that are already expensive to insure—like sports cars, performance trims, and luxury models. The price difference is usually about the car (and how it’s driven), not the color.

For example, fast cars generally cost more to insure than practical vehicles, and certain body styles can be pricier too, like convertibles and 2-door coupes. Meanwhile, family-focused vehicles like a minivan are often cheaper because they’re statistically associated with lower-risk driving and can be less expensive to repair.

That’s why “color” can look like the culprit when the bigger factor is actually how your type of car affects your insurance rates.

3) People confuse attention with pricing

Bright colors are more noticeable, which can fuel the belief that red cars get more tickets—or that insurers charge more because drivers get pulled over more. But insurers don’t price your policy based on how “attention-grabbing” the paint is. They price based on measurable risk factors like violations, accidents, and claims.

If you’ve had issues in the past and you’re working your way back to better pricing, focus on what actually moves the needle—your record, claims history, and shopping around. This guide can help: how to move from high-risk to standard car insurance.

One Exception: Custom Paint (or Wraps) Can Affect a Claim

Standard factory colors typically won’t change your rate. But if you’ve paid extra for a custom paint job, specialty wrap, or aftermarket appearance upgrades, that could affect coverage because it changes the cost to repair or replace the vehicle. If you’ve invested money into appearance upgrades, ask your insurer whether you need custom parts/equipment coverage (names vary by company). Progressive, for one, tells drivers who repaint their car to add its optional custom parts and equipment coverage.

My advice is to buy the color you like and spend your effort on the things that move the price: the model, your deductible and your driving record. If you add a custom paint job or wrap, call your insurer the same week and ask about custom parts and equipment coverage, because a standard policy may only pay to restore factory paint.

FAQs on Car Color and Insurance Rates

Bottom Line: Your Car’s Color Doesn’t Affect Insurance Rates

In general, you can pick the color you like without worrying about a “red car surcharge.” Insurers focus on risk and repair costs—things like the vehicle’s specs, whether it’s a new car with expensive tech, whether it’s used, and the driver’s record and profile.

If you want the best price, your best moves are comparing carriers, matching coverage to your needs, and choosing a vehicle that’s affordable to repair. If you’re shopping, start with a shortlist of reputable providers: the best auto insurance companies in America.

Sources

Checked October 15, 2026