Is It Cheaper to Insure a Chevy Camaro or a Ford Mustang?

Last Updated on February 5, 2026

When it comes to modern American muscle cars, two names dominate the conversation: the Chevy Camaro and the Ford Mustang. They’re fast, fun, and iconic—but they’re also usually more expensive to insure than the average sedan.

If you’re cross-shopping these two, the “real” cost isn’t just what you pay at the dealership. Insurance can add a meaningful amount to your monthly budget (especially if you’re young, have a few tickets, or want full coverage). Here’s what typically makes one cheaper than the other—and how to estimate your own costs.

Mustangs and Camaros are often similarly priced to insure, but the “winner” depends heavily on trim, model year, theft risk in your ZIP code, and your driver profile.
Because Camaro production ended after the 2024 model year, many shoppers are really comparing a newer Mustang to a used Camaro—repair costs and parts availability can affect rates.
Minimum liability can look affordable, but full coverage (collision + comprehensive) is usually what drives costs up for muscle cars.
The easiest way to save is to quote both cars with the exact VINs and compare multiple insurers at renewal—rate differences can be bigger than the car-to-car difference.

Table Of Contents

Quick Answer: Is a Camaro or Mustang Cheaper to Insure?
Why Muscle Cars Often Cost More to Insure
Coverage Types You’ll Need for a Mustang or Camaro
Real-World Insurance Costs: What Recent Data Suggests
When a Mustang Is Often Cheaper (and When a Camaro Is Often Cheaper)
FAQs: Camaro vs. Mustang Insurance
How to Lower Your Mustang or Camaro Insurance Cost

Quick Answer: Is a Camaro or Mustang Cheaper to Insure?

In many cases, they’re priced very similarly when you compare similar trims, drivers, and coverage. A slight edge can swing either way based on:

Trim and engine (base models vs. V8 performance trims)
Theft risk in your area
Repair costs and parts pricing
Your age, driving record, ZIP code, and credit-based insurance factors

One big 2025 reality check: new Camaros are no longer being produced after the 2024 model year, so most shoppers are comparing a new(ish) Mustang against a used Camaro. That doesn’t automatically make Camaro insurance higher or lower—but it can affect repair costs, parts availability, and the kinds of trims you’ll find on the market.

Why Muscle Cars Often Cost More to Insure

Even if you have a clean record, insurers rate sports/muscle cars differently than “everyday” commuter cars (like the models on lists of the cheapest cars to drive). The most common vehicle-related pricing factors include:

Higher claim severity: faster cars tend to produce higher-speed accidents and more expensive repairs.
Theft risk: performance models can be targeted more often, which raises comprehensive insurance costs.
Repair and parts costs: specialty wheels, performance brakes, body panels, sensors, and lighting add up quickly.
Safety ratings and crash data: insurers factor in crash outcomes and repairability—learn more about how safety ratings impact insurance rates.
Body style: both are coupes/convertibles, and 2-door cars can be more expensive to insure than similar 4-door models.

If you want to compare safety ratings for the specific model year you’re buying, the National Highway Traffic Safety Administration (NHTSA) is a good place to start.

Coverage Types You’ll Need for a Mustang or Camaro

Your coverage choices can matter as much as the car. No matter which one you drive, you’ll need auto liability insurance to legally drive in nearly every state. Liability pays for other people’s injuries and property damage when you cause an accident (see what happens if you’re at fault in an accident).

Also remember: the price difference between the cars can look “small” if you’re comparing minimum coverage, but the gap can widen once you add full coverage.

Recommended Add-Ons for Muscle Cars

If you’re financing or leasing—or you’d struggle to replace the car out-of-pocket—consider these common add-ons:

Collision: helps pay to repair/replace your car after an at-fault crash or single-car accident.
Comprehensive: helps with non-collision losses like theft and weather—also see whether insurance covers vandalism and whether it covers theft.
Uninsured/underinsured motorist: important protection if you’re hit by a driver with no insurance (or not enough)—and yes, in some situations you can sue an uninsured driver.
Gap insurance: can be valuable on newer/financed vehicles if the car is totaled and you owe more than it’s worth—here’s when gap insurance is worth it on a used car.

Real-World Insurance Costs: What Recent Data Suggests

Because insurers price policies based on your personal rating factors, there’s no “one” number that applies to everyone. But recent quote-aggregator research often puts both cars in a similar range when comparing mainstream trims.

For example, some recent national averages (as reported by major comparison sites) show monthly premiums for a Mustang and Camaro that are close—sometimes separated by only a few dollars. Other studies that model a specific sample driver profile can show a wider gap.

Why the Numbers Don’t Always Match

If one source says a Mustang is cheaper and another says a Camaro is cheaper, it’s usually because of differences in:

Driver assumptions (age, credit, claims history, miles driven)
Coverage assumptions (liability-only vs. full coverage, deductible choices)
Model years and trims being compared (base vs. V8 vs. track packages)
Location (theft rates and repair costs vary a lot by ZIP code)

When a Mustang Is Often Cheaper (and When a Camaro Is Often Cheaper)

Here’s a practical way to think about it:

A Mustang may come out cheaper if…

You’re comparing a newer base trim Mustang against a higher-trim Camaro (or a Camaro with expensive aftermarket parts).
Your insurer gives better sports-car pricing for Ford models in your state.
You can qualify for better discounts (bundling, telematics, multi-car, good-student, etc.).

A Camaro may come out cheaper if…

You’re comparing similar power levels and the Camaro is older/cheaper to replace.
You choose a lower-risk trim and keep comprehensive/collision deductibles higher.
Your ZIP code has more theft/claim activity for Mustangs than Camaros (this varies by region).

FAQs: Camaro vs. Mustang Insurance

Is a Mustang or a Camaro usually cheaper to insure?

For many drivers, they’re very close—especially when you compare similar trims (base-to-base or V8-to-V8). The cheaper option often comes down to your ZIP code, age, driving record, credit-based factors, and the exact model year/trim.

Does the engine (V6/V8) affect insurance a lot?

It can. Higher-horsepower trims often cost more to insure because they’re associated with higher claim severity and higher repair costs. That said, some insurers price trims surprisingly close, so it’s best to quote the specific VIN.

Are coupes more expensive to insure than sedans?

Often, yes. Two-door sports cars can be rated as higher risk than similar four-door vehicles, and they can also have higher theft exposure and repair costs. But the impact varies by insurer and driver profile.

Will a used Camaro be cheaper to insure than a new Mustang?

Not automatically. A lower vehicle value can reduce certain costs, but theft risk, parts/repair pricing, and your coverage choices (like comprehensive and collision deductibles) can offset that. Always compare quotes using VINs for both vehicles.

What coverage should I carry on a Mustang or Camaro?

At a minimum, you need your state’s required liability coverage. Many drivers also add collision and comprehensive (especially if financing), plus uninsured/underinsured motorist coverage for extra protection. Your budget and risk tolerance should guide the final decision.

How can I lower insurance costs on a muscle car?

Shop quotes from multiple insurers, ask about all available discounts, consider higher deductibles if you have savings, reduce mileage when possible, and park in a secure location. Keeping a clean record is also one of the biggest long-term savings drivers.

Should I compare liability-only or full coverage when shopping?

Compare the same coverage on both cars. Liability-only can make a policy look cheap, but full coverage (collision + comprehensive) is where sports cars often get expensive. Matching coverage and deductibles is the only fair comparison.

How to Lower Your Mustang or Camaro Insurance Cost

No matter which car you choose, the fastest way to lower costs is to compare multiple insurers. Many drivers save the most by switching auto insurance companies at renewal instead of staying loyal to one carrier.

Other high-impact moves include raising deductibles (if you have savings to back them up), improving your credit profile, reducing annual mileage, parking in a garage, and asking your insurer about anti-theft discounts. And while you might see headlines about car insurance getting cheaper, muscle cars are still typically rated as higher-risk vehicles—so shopping around matters.

Bottom line: the “cheaper to insure” winner depends on the exact Mustang/Camaro you’re buying and your driver profile. Get quotes using the VINs of the two specific cars you’re considering to see the real difference.

Stop Overpaying for Car Insurance