Is Main Street America Good for Auto Insurance?

Last Updated on October 16, 2026

Main Street America no longer sells personal auto insurance. It announced in August 2024 that it was leaving personal lines, and its own brand release of March 20, 2025 says what the company sells now: “a wide range of commercial insurance, fidelity and surety bond products as well as a full suite of farm and ranch coverages throughout the United States.” Car insurance for your own car is not on that list. No independent agent can quote you a new Main Street America auto policy today.

This is a company tightening its focus, and nothing more than that. Main Street America has been writing insurance since 1923, it belongs to the American Family Insurance Group, and AM Best affirmed that group’s A (Excellent) financial strength rating with a stable outlook on September 24, 2025, naming Main Street America Assurance Company and Main Street America Protection Insurance Company among the affiliates the rating covers. The company describes the move as “tightening focus and leaning further into the tremendous opportunity that exists in the commercial lines space.” If your car is still insured by Main Street America, the company behind that policy is in good health.

So if you still have a policy, do not cancel anything. It stays in force until it ends or is replaced, a claim on it gets paid, and Main Street America still runs a personal insurance login and a customer care line. What the company has not published is what happens to in-force personal auto policies at renewal, which makes one phone call worth making: ask your independent agent which carrier they would move you to and what the price looks like, well before your renewal date. If you are shopping in an expensive market like Florida, get more than one quote while you have time.

Main Street America at a Glance

A healthy American Family Insurance Group member that left personal lines in 2024. It writes commercial, farm and ranch, and surety business today, and no longer sells personal auto.

Quick facts

Status: no longer sells personal auto insurance

Left personal lines: announced August 2024

Sells now: commercial, farm and ranch, and surety bonds

Part of: American Family Insurance Group

Claims on past policies: still handled, online or by phone

Summary

Bottom line: There is no personal auto policy here to buy. Main Street America left personal lines in 2024 and sells commercial, farm and ranch, and fidelity and surety products now. Existing policyholders are with a financially strong company and should talk to their agent about where they go next.

Main Street America has written insurance since 1923 and sells through independent agents. Its personal auto book is the part that ended: the company announced the personal lines exit in August 2024, and its March 2025 brand release lists only commercial insurance, fidelity and surety bonds, and farm and ranch coverage. The company itself is an American Family Insurance Group member and AM Best affirmed the group’s A (Excellent) rating with a stable outlook in September 2025, so an in-force policy is well backed. Claims, billing and ID cards still run as usual through the agent, the customer care line and the personal insurance login.

Best for

  • Anyone still holding a policy who needs to service it, pay a bill or file a claim
  • Businesses and farms, which is what the company writes today
  • Agents looking for commercial, farm and ranch, or surety and fidelity markets

Not ideal for

  • Anyone shopping for a new personal auto policy, in any state
  • Drivers hoping to add a car or a driver to a brand that still writes personal lines
  • Policyholders who want a published plan for what happens at renewal, which the company has not released

How Main Street America Auto Insurance Works

Main Street America has always distributed through independent agents rather than selling direct, and that is still how the commercial, farm and surety business reaches customers. For a personal auto policyholder, the agent is now the person who services the policy you have and the person who will place you with a different carrier. Ask them to price the move the same way they would a renewal, and to check which auto insurance discounts carry over to the new company, because discount names and rules change from carrier to carrier.

Quick tip: Pull out your declarations page and find the “writing company” line. On a Main Street America auto policy it names a specific insurer, often NGM Insurance Company, Main Street America Assurance Company or Main Street America Protection Insurance Company. That name, not the brand, is what you give a claims rep or a state insurance department, and it is what to check against the AM Best rating.

Main Street America Auto Insurance Coverage Options

The table below is for policyholders reading their own declarations page, since nobody can buy this coverage new. These are the building blocks a Main Street America auto policy is made of, and the optional pieces that may or may not be on yours depending on the state, the vehicle and the writing company. It doubles as a checklist when you compare a replacement policy, because what you want is the same coverage, not the same price.

CoverageWhat It Typically Pays ForWhen It’s Most Useful
Bodily Injury LiabilityInjuries you cause to others, including medical bills and legal defense (up to your limits).Required in many states and essential for protecting assets if you’re sued.
Property Damage LiabilityDamage you cause to someone else’s vehicle or property (fence, pole, building, etc.).Required in many states; higher limits can matter in serious crashes.
Collision CoverageRepairs to your car after a crash or rollover, regardless of fault (minus your deductible).Important for newer vehicles, financed/leased cars, or anyone who can’t easily replace a totaled vehicle.
Comprehensive CoverageNon-collision damage such as theft, vandalism, hail, falling objects, animal strikes, and many weather events.Commonly required by lenders/lessors; useful if you want protection beyond crashes.
Medical Payments Coverage (MedPay)Medical expenses for you and passengers after an accident, typically regardless of fault (up to the MedPay limit).Helps with out-of-pocket medical costs, deductibles, and gaps in health coverage.
Uninsured/Underinsured Motorist CoverageInjuries (and in some states property damage) when the at-fault driver has no insurance or not enough coverage.Especially valuable in areas with higher uninsured-driver rates or if you want stronger injury protection.
Optional Endorsements (Availability Varies)New vehicle replacement, diminishing deductible programs, full safety glass, roadside assistance, loan/lease protection (GAP), accident forgiveness, and OEM parts coverage are common examples.Best for drivers who want fewer “surprises” after a claim (for example: glass claims, towing, or a total loss on a financed car).

Main Street America Auto Insurance Discounts

These are the discount categories that applied to Main Street America personal auto policies. They are worth reading now for one reason: when your agent quotes you a replacement, this is the list to walk through with them so nothing you were already getting credit for gets dropped quietly. You will not qualify for every line, and eligibility rules differ by carrier and state, so get them confirmed in writing before you bind the new policy.

CategoryCommon Discount ExamplesWhat Insurers Usually Look For
Policy & HouseholdMulti-policy (bundling), multi-vehicle, loyalty programs, and new-customer offersMultiple eligible policies, multiple drivers/vehicles on one policy, or tenure with the insurer.
Driver & Studentgood student, student away from school, and mature operator programsDocumentation such as grades, enrollment status, residence, age, and household details.
Coverage Choicesminimum coverage vs. higher limits and add-onsLower premiums usually come with lower protection; lenders/lessors may require collision and comprehensive.
Driving Recordclaims-free and violation-free discountsA clean record over a defined time window (rules differ by state and insurer).
Training & Behaviordefensive driving or approved training programsCompletion certificates and eligibility rules based on age and state.
Vehicle Safetynewer vehicles vs. older vehicles, anti-theft devices, and safety-based pricing influenced by vehicle safety ratingsFactory-installed safety equipment, anti-theft features, and vehicle characteristics tied to claim frequency/severity.
Payments & Billingpay in full, paperless billing, and electronic funds transferPayment method, billing preferences, and whether fees apply to certain methods.

Financial Strength and Company Background

Main Street America has been operating since 1923 and describes itself as a “Leader in property and casualty insurance, including commercial lines and farm and ranch,” backed by the financial strength of the American Family Insurance Group. That backing is current and checkable: on September 24, 2025 AM Best affirmed the A (Excellent) financial strength rating with a stable outlook for American Family Mutual Insurance Company, S.I. and its core affiliates, and the list of affiliates names Main Street America Assurance Company, Main Street America Protection Insurance Company, MSA Insurance Company, NGM Insurance Company and Old Dominion Insurance Company. Leaving personal lines was a business decision, not a sign of trouble. For broader context on the parent organization and its brands, see our American Family Insurance review.

Customer Experience and Claims

Service on an in-force policy has not stopped. Main Street America still publishes a customer care line for policy status, billing and ID card requests, open Monday to Friday from 8 a.m. to 8 p.m. Eastern, and it still runs a personal insurance login at myaccount.msainsurance.com. Claims can be reported online or by phone. Because the company sells through independent agents, the day-to-day experience depends on your local agency and on the writing company named on your declarations page, and that is doubly true now that the agency is also the one finding your next carrier.

If you still have a policy, it helps to:

  • Ask your agent, in writing, what they plan to do with your policy at renewal and which carriers they would quote.
  • Confirm how claims are reported (online vs. phone) and which phone number is used for after-hours reporting.
  • Ask how repairs are handled (preferred shop programs, parts options, and supplement approvals) and what documentation is typically required.
  • Save a copy of your current declarations page before anything changes. It is the record of the limits, deductibles and endorsements you want the next policy to match.

Main Street America Pros and Cons

ProsCons
An in-force policy sits behind an American Family Insurance Group member, rated A (Excellent) by AM Best with a stable outlook as of September 24, 2025.You cannot buy one. Main Street America left personal lines in 2024, so there is no new personal auto policy in any state.
Claims, billing and ID cards still run normally, online, through customer care or through your agent.The company has not published what happens to in-force personal auto policies at renewal, so you are asking your agent rather than reading an announcement.
Your independent agent already has the rest of the market and can move you without a gap in coverage.Moving means new underwriting at a different company, so your price and your discounts get recalculated.
Shopping a replacement is a chance to lower the cost of car insurance without cutting critical protections.Discount names and eligibility rules differ by carrier and state, so confirm in writing what is actually applied to the new quote.

Final Word on Main Street America Auto Insurance

For a shopper, this one is short: Main Street America is not an option for car insurance any more, and has not been since it left personal lines in 2024. If a website or an agent offers you a Main Street America auto quote, something is out of date. The company is alive, well rated and busy writing business and farm insurance, and that is where its independent agents will point you now.

For anyone still holding a policy, the job is a handoff rather than an emergency. Review your declarations page for limits, deductibles, endorsements and listed drivers and vehicles, keep your agent’s number and the claims number handy, and get a replacement quote lined up ahead of your renewal date instead of after it.

My advice: call the agent, not the company. The agent holds the rest of the market and can run your exact limits through three or four carriers in an afternoon. People who wait for a letter end up taking whatever is quick, and quick is rarely cheap.

Main Street America Company Information
Mailing AddressP.O. Box 2300
Keene, NH 03431
Front Desk (General Information)(800) 258-5310
Customer Care (policy status, billing, ID cards)(877) 927-5672, Monday to Friday, 8 a.m. to 8 p.m. ET
Roadside Assistance and Agent Claim Reporting(877) 425-2467
Claims Mailing Address6000 American Pkwy
Madison, WI 53783
Personal Insurance Loginhttps://myaccount.msainsurance.com
Website URLhttps://www.msainsurance.com/

FAQs on Main Street America Auto Insurance

Sources

Checked October 5, 2026