How Long Can An Auto Insurance Claim Stay Open?

There’s no single deadline that applies everywhere. Some straightforward claims close in days or a few weeks, while complex claims can stay open for months—or longer—especially when liability is disputed, injuries are involved, or repairs keep changing.

In general, a claim stays open until one (or more) of these happens:

The insurer pays what it owes (repair, total loss, medical, rental, etc.) and closes the file.
You and the insurer agree on a final settlement amount and sign a release (common with injury claims).
The claim is denied and the file is closed (sometimes reopened later if new information appears).
Subrogation is still in progress (your insurer may keep parts of the file open while trying to recover money from the at-fault party).

What Usually Determines Claim Timing

How fast your insurer can close a claim depends on a mix of company procedures, state rules, and the facts of the accident. These are the biggest factors that affect timing:

Liability: Whether fault is clear or disputed
Claim type: Property damage vs. injuries vs. theft/total loss
Evidence and documentation: Photos, police report, witness statements, medical records, repair estimates
Coverage questions: Whether the policy applies, limits, deductibles, exclusions, and who is covered
Repair complexity: Parts delays, supplements, hidden damage, shop backlogs
Legal complexity: Multiple vehicles, multiple insurers, disputed injuries, attorneys involved

Even when you’re not at fault, delays can happen while the insurer confirms details and negotiates with other carriers.

State Regulations and “Reasonable” Claim Handling

Many states have consumer-protection rules that require insurers to handle claims promptly and communicate within specific timeframes (for example, acknowledging the claim, responding to communications, and providing updates). The exact timelines vary by state and by claim situation.

To find your state’s rules (and to file a complaint if a claim is being mishandled), contact your state Department of Insurance. The NAIC has a directory here: Insurance Departments (NAIC).

Company Processes That Can Slow (or Speed) a Claim

Each insurer has its own workflow—how fast it assigns an adjuster, how it inspects damage, and how it issues payments. You can sometimes speed things up by following the insurer’s preferred process for how claims are filed and responding quickly to requests for documents.

Once the insurer has enough information, settlement often becomes a negotiation step. If you’re trying to improve the outcome (especially on vehicle value or damage scope), it helps to understand how to negotiate an auto insurance settlement.

Claim Type Matters: Injury vs. Property Damage

Different claims naturally move at different speeds.

Bodily injury claims often stay open longer

It’s common for injury claims to remain open until treatment is finished (or at least stable) because the final cost of care may not be clear right away. These claims relate to bodily injury, and settlement often involves medical records, lost wages documentation, and negotiations over pain and suffering.

Also, there’s a legal “clock” in the background: injury disputes are governed by statutes of limitations. If that deadline passes, you can lose legal leverage—or the ability—to pursue payment through the courts, which can impact how the claim resolves. If you’re unsure about coverage or deadlines, it’s smart to get advice early.

Property damage claims can close faster—but repairs can create delays

Property damage is often more straightforward, but it can still drag out when the shop finds hidden damage, parts are backordered, or the insurer disputes the repair scope. Property damage payments are tied to property damage liability (for damage you cause) or collision/comprehensive (for your own vehicle), depending on who is paying.

How Long Do You Have to File vs. How Long a Claim Can Stay Open

These are two different issues. Your policy (and state law) may set deadlines for reporting or filing, while the insurer’s investigation and settlement process determines how long the claim stays open after it’s filed. If you’re worried you waited too long, review how long you have to file an insurance claim after a car accident before you assume your claim is still valid.

What to Do If Your Insurance Claim Is Taking Too Long

If a claim feels stalled, take practical steps before assuming “bad faith.” Start with documentation and clear requests:

Ask for a written status update with what’s still needed, who is responsible, and the next deadline.
Escalate to a supervisor if your adjuster is unresponsive or timelines keep slipping.
Send missing documents promptly (photos, estimates, medical bills, proof of ownership, etc.).
Confirm what’s covered so you don’t wait for something your policy doesn’t pay for.

Insurers are generally required to keep you informed. If you need help navigating updates, read how insurers share claim information and how to check the status of an auto insurance claim.

If you’ve cooperated fully, the delay is unreasonable, and you’re not getting clear answers, you can file a complaint with your state Department of Insurance or speak with an attorney—especially if injuries are involved or you suspect the claim is being unfairly handled. And if the carrier says it won’t pay, review how and why insurers deny claims so you understand the exact reason and your options.

FAQs on How Long an Auto Insurance Claim Can Stay Open

What does it mean when an insurance claim is still open?

An open claim means the insurer hasn’t finished the process—investigation, coverage review, damage evaluation, and/or final settlement. The company may still be waiting on documents, repair supplements, medical records, or a liability decision before it can close the file.

How long do most car insurance claims take to settle?

Simple property damage claims may settle relatively quickly once the vehicle is inspected and repairs are approved. Claims involving disputed fault, serious injuries, theft investigations, or total losses often take longer because more documentation and negotiation is required.

Why is my property damage claim taking so long?

Common reasons include delays getting a police report, slow inspections, repair shop backlogs, parts shortages, and “supplements” (additional damage found after teardown). Disputes about repair scope or total loss value can also extend the timeline.

Do injury claims stay open longer than vehicle damage claims?

Often, yes. Injury claims can remain open until treatment is complete or stable because the final cost and long-term impact may not be clear right away. Settling too early can leave you responsible for later medical expenses that weren’t included in the settlement.

Can my insurer close the claim without paying me?

Yes. If the insurer determines the loss isn’t covered, lacks required proof, or believes a policy exclusion applies, it may deny the claim and close the file. In some situations a claim can be reopened if new information becomes available or an error is corrected.

What should I do if my adjuster isn’t responding?

Request a written status update, document your calls/emails, and ask to speak with a supervisor or claims manager. If communication remains poor or delays seem unreasonable, you can contact your state Department of Insurance to ask about complaint options.

Is there a deadline for settling an auto insurance claim?

Many states require insurers to handle claims promptly and communicate within set timeframes, but the exact rules vary by state. The settlement timeline also depends on the facts of the case—especially disputes over fault, injuries, and the amount of damage.

How Long Will Your Claim Stay Open? The Bottom Line

A claim can stay open as long as it takes to investigate, document, and settle—sometimes quickly, sometimes for months. The best way to keep things moving is to document everything, respond quickly, request clear timelines, and escalate when communication breaks down.

Get FREE
Insurance Quotes

How Long Can An Auto Insurance Claim Stay Open?

Key Takeaways