Why the Cheapest Insurance Isn’t Always the Best Insurance
Last Updated on December 8, 2025
Cheap car insurance looks great on your monthly budget—but it can backfire badly when you need it most. Bare-minimum policies and rock-bottom premiums often come with serious trade-offs in coverage, protection, and service. Before you buy the cheapest policy you can find, it’s important to understand what you’re giving up.
Below, we’ll walk through the benefits and risks of cheap car insurance—and why “cheapest” is not always “best.”
Key Takeaways
- Cheap car insurance often means low liability limits, no protection for your own car, and higher deductibles.
- Even minor accidents can exceed minimum liability limits, leaving you personally responsible for large bills.
- Liability-only policies do not pay to repair or replace your own vehicle if you cause a crash.
- It’s important to balance affordability with adequate coverage rather than chasing the lowest possible premium.
The Benefits of Cheap Car Insurance
First, some good news: cheap car insurance isn’t always bad. In fact, in some situations getting cheap car insurance can be a practical short-term solution—especially if money is tight.
Potential benefits of cheap or bare-minimum coverage include:
- Lower monthly payments: You keep more money in your pocket now, which can be critical if you’re living paycheck to paycheck.
- Savings if you never file a claim: If you go years without an accident or needing to file a claim, the savings can add up.
- Paying only for what you absolutely need: Minimum liability lets you legally drive without paying for extra coverage.
- DIY “self-insurance” option: Some people invest the money saved on premiums into a savings account, then use that fund to cover damages that exceed their policy limits after a collision.
Cheap insurance is only a problem when something goes wrong—when you have an accident, cause property damage, or face medical bills. Many drivers never think about coverage limits until after a claim is denied or a bill arrives.
Downsides of Cheap Car Insurance: Why It’s (Usually) a Bad Idea
Drivers with low-cost, minimum-coverage policies often face harsh consequences after an accident. The whole point of insurance is to protect you from large, unexpected costs. If your coverage is too thin, it may barely do that.
Is it really worth exposing yourself to serious financial risk just to save a few hundred dollars a year? Here are some of the biggest downsides of buying the cheapest possible policy.
Even Small Accidents Can Exceed Your Coverage Limits
Cheap liability policies usually come with low coverage limits. Many financial experts, including Dave Ramsey, recommend at least $500,000 of liability coverage per accident—and some recommend $1–$2 million for solid protection.
Bare-minimum policies might provide just $10,000–$30,000 of property damage or bodily injury coverage. That sounds like a lot until you consider:
- Modern vehicles are expensive to repair or replace
- Medical care and ambulance bills add up fast
- Multiple injured passengers can multiply costs dramatically
It doesn’t take much to blow past a $10,000 limit—even in what looks like a “minor” accident. Anything beyond your limits comes out of your pocket.
Here’s a quick comparison between state minimum insurance limits and the coverage experts recommend for real protection.
| Coverage Type | State Minimum Coverage | Recommended Coverage | Why It Matters |
|---|---|---|---|
| Bodily Injury Liability | $10,000–$50,000 per person $20,000–$100,000 per accident | $250,000 per person $500,000 per accident | Medical bills can exceed minimums easily. Higher limits protect your assets from lawsuits. |
| Property Damage Liability | $5,000–$25,000 | $100,000+ | New vehicles often cost $30k–$60k. One accident can exceed minimum limits. |
| Uninsured / Underinsured Motorist | Often NOT required | Match your liability limits (e.g., $250k / $500k) | Protects you if the at-fault driver has little or no insurance—critical in many states. |
| Collision Coverage | Not included | Add if your car is worth more than $3,000–$5,000 | Pays to repair YOUR vehicle if you cause a crash. |
| Comprehensive Coverage | Not included | Add if your car is worth more than $3,000–$5,000 | Protects against theft, fire, weather, vandalism, and animal collisions. |
| Medical Payments / PIP | $0–$5,000 (varies by state) | $10,000–$25,000 | Helps pay your medical bills regardless of fault. |
| Deductible | $1,000–$2,500+ | $500–$1,000 | Lower deductibles mean less out-of-pocket cost at claim time. |
Your Own Vehicle Often Isn’t Protected
The cheapest policies are almost always liability-only. That means they only pay for damage you cause to others—not for damage to your own vehicle.
If you cause a crash:
- Your liability coverage may pay for the other driver’s repairs and medical bills.
- You get nothing for your own car repairs or replacement.
If you rely on your car to work or care for your family, this can be devastating. Without comprehensive or collision coverage, you may be on your own.
You Could Be Left Without a Vehicle
Ask yourself honestly:
- Could you afford to repair your car out of pocket if it was badly damaged?
- Could you afford to replace your car if it was totaled?
- What happens if you have to go without a vehicle for weeks or months?
Many people buy the cheapest insurance precisely because they don’t have extra savings. But that also means they may be unable to fix or replace their vehicle after a serious accident. If your policy doesn’t cover your own car, you could be stuck without transportation when you need it most.
You May Receive Lower-Priority Service
While insurers won’t say this outright, it’s common for companies to provide more robust service to customers with higher-level coverage or multiple bundled policies.
Policyholders with only basic liability may find:
- Longer response times
- Less flexible claims handling
- Fewer perks (like rental reimbursement or roadside assistance)
This doesn’t matter—until you actually need help, and then it matters a lot.
Cheap Insurance Usually Means Higher Deductibles
One of the easiest ways to cut your premium is to raise your deductible. Instead of a $500 deductible, you might choose $1,000 or more to reduce your monthly bill.
The trade-off is simple:
- Cheaper monthly premium
- Much higher out-of-pocket cost when you file a claim
With a high deductible, even relatively small accidents can be expensive. If you can’t comfortably afford your deductible, your coverage may not provide the protection you think it does.
FAQ’s on Cheap Insurance Risks
Conclusion: Think Carefully Before Buying the Cheapest Car Insurance
Cheap car insurance might look smart in the short term—but in a serious accident, it can be financially devastating. In minor crashes, you may have to pay to repair or replace your own vehicle. In major crashes, you could be held personally responsible for tens or hundreds of thousands of dollars in damage beyond your coverage limits.
That doesn’t mean you should overpay for coverage. It does mean you should balance price with protection. Before you buy the absolute cheapest policy, consider:
- Whether your liability limits are high enough
- Whether your own vehicle is protected
- Whether you can afford a high deductible
- Whether you have savings to fall back on after a bad accident
Cheap car insurance can be a useful short-term solution—but it should never be your long-term strategy for financial protection on the road.
