Is Encompass Insurance Good?

Last Updated on October 16, 2026

Encompass Insurance can be a good option for drivers who prefer working with an independent agent and want strong bundle-friendly coverage options. The tradeoffs are that availability varies by state and many shoppers will need to contact an agent (rather than completing everything through a quick online quote tool).

Below is a practical, up-to-date look at Encompass auto insurance—what it offers, who it’s best for, how discounts typically work, and what to consider before buying a policy.

Our Rating of Encompass Auto Insurance

Encompass is an independent-agent insurer built around bundling and tiered coverage features, with availability that varies by state and a complaint record worse than average.

3.2

out of 5

Checked October 14, 2026 · How we score insurers

Customer satisfaction: we couldn’t confirm a 2026 J.D. Power rating for Encompass, so it gets an average score for this part.

Independent-agent model Bundle-friendly Tier-based features High complaint ratio

Summary

Bottom line: Encompass is worth a quote for drivers who want independent-agent guidance and plan to bundle auto with home or other policies, but it draws more complaints than an insurer its size should, and you’ll need to confirm state availability and discount eligibility.

Encompass is a personal lines insurer sold primarily through independent agents, with coverage often organized into tiers (commonly Special, Deluxe, and Elite) where features can vary by package level and state. The company offers standard auto protections plus potential add-ons like accident forgiveness, roadside assistance, new car replacement, lease/loan gap coverage, and electronic device coverage, depending on eligibility and where you live. Because quoting and binding are frequently handled through an agent (rather than a quick online checkout), it can be less convenient for shoppers who want a fully self-serve process, and it’s important to confirm which discounts apply before you purchase.

Best for

  • Households bundling auto with home, renters, or other personal policies
  • Drivers who prefer working with an independent agent for coverage guidance
  • Shoppers who want tier-based features like accident forgiveness or enhanced replacement options (where available)

Not ideal for

  • Drivers who want instant online quoting and fully digital purchase
  • Shoppers in areas where Encompass is not currently writing new auto policies
  • People who don’t want coverage features packaged into higher-tier options

About Encompass Insurance

Encompass is a personal lines insurer that focuses on auto and property coverage, including home and renters insurance. Allstate bought CNA Personal Insurance in 1999 and renamed it Encompass in 2000, and it has been Allstate’s independent-agent brand ever since. Allstate’s own year-end 2025 filing still lists seven Encompass companies as members of the group.

Encompass policies are typically sold through independent insurance agents. That model can be a benefit if you want help selecting coverage, comparing options, and adjusting limits—but it can also feel less “instant” than carriers that push fully online purchases.

Where Encompass Is Available

Encompass operates in many states, and the list has been shrinking. New Jersey’s Department of Banking and Insurance lists both of its Encompass companies as “not accepting any new business,” and the Massachusetts Division of Insurance reported that the Encompass company there “ceased writing new business in 2018.” Encompass publishes no state-by-state list, so the only reliable way to find out whether it is writing new auto policies in your ZIP code is to ask an independent agent to check eligibility.

What Types of Auto Insurance Does Encompass Offer?

Encompass offers standard car insurance protections most drivers expect, including liability coverage required by state law, plus optional protections like collision and comprehensive. Coverage is organized into tiers, and many features are packaged by tier. Encompass has a separate page on its site for each one: the EncompassOne Special, Deluxe and Elite policies.

EncompassOne is the package approach that combines auto with home and other personal insurance in one policy structure. Which features come with which tier varies by state, and Encompass does not publish the tier comparison, so ask the agent for it in writing.

Encompass’s auto insurance page names accident forgiveness, roadside assistance, new car replacement and loan/lease gap coverage. It does not say which tier includes which feature, and that varies by state, so get the ones that matter to you confirmed in writing before you buy. The phone numbers and the address further down come from Encompass’s contact page.

Depending on your state and policy tier, add-ons and features may include:

  • Accident forgiveness: May help prevent a surcharge after a qualifying at-fault accident, typically if you meet eligibility rules and maintain a clean history for a period of time.
  • Roadside assistance: Usually covers common emergencies like towing, jump-starts, locksmith services, and flat tire help.
  • New car replacement: May offer an upgraded settlement option for newer vehicles that are totaled, subject to timing and eligibility rules.
  • Lease/loan gap coverage: Can help cover the difference between what your car is worth and what you still owe if the vehicle is totaled.
  • Electronic device coverage: May increase protection for certain electronics beyond what a standard policy would cover, depending on the item and how it’s installed or used.

What Discounts Does Encompass Offer?

Discount availability depends on the state, the underwriting company, and your policy tier. Many drivers can qualify for more than one discount, especially when bundling multiple policies.

Encompass’s auto page lists a safe driving bonus and discounts for a future effective date, Encompass Easy Pay, a new car, homeowners, good payers, defensive drivers, anti-lock brakes, anti-theft devices, passive restraint systems, good students, driver training and resident students. Common discount categories include:

Quick tip: Ask your agent to run a “discount audit” before you bind coverage. Many discounts require documentation (student status, course completion, safety devices) and may not apply automatically.

What Are Encompass’s Rates Like?

Encompass pricing is highly individualized. Rates depend on driving history, location, vehicle type, credit-based insurance score (where allowed), mileage, coverages selected, and whether you bundle home and auto. Because Encompass is commonly sold through independent agents, many drivers see the most value when they’re packaging multiple policies or choosing higher coverage tiers with added features.

If you’re price-shopping, the only reliable way to compare Encompass is to request the same limits and deductibles from multiple carriers and review the coverages side-by-side—not just the monthly premium.

What Is Encompass’s Customer Service Like?

Customer experience with Encompass is usually shaped by two things: your independent agent and the claims process. Many policyholders like having a dedicated agent for questions, billing changes, and coverage adjustments. On the other hand, shoppers who want a fully self-serve experience may find the agent-based model less convenient.

When evaluating service quality, look at a mix of indicators: financial strength ratings (which help show an insurer’s ability to pay claims), independent customer satisfaction studies (see how JD Power auto insurance rankings work), and complaint trends reported to state regulators. For financial strength, A.M. Best affirmed the Allstate Insurance Group at A+ (Superior), stable, on September 2, 2026, and its full listing includes seven Encompass companies, Encompass Insurance Company among them. The two New Jersey Encompass companies sit in a separate Allstate New Jersey group rated A- (Excellent), so check the exact company on your declarations page. Here is what the AM Best ratings mean when comparing insurers.

The complaint record is weaker. Using NAIC complaint data for 2023 through 2025, we calculate a complaint index of 1.85 for the nine companies that write Encompass auto policies, based on 192 confirmed complaints. An index of 1.00 is what companies of that size would be expected to draw, so Encompass drew nearly twice its expected share.

Encompass also provides online account access for many policy functions (billing, documents, and policy details). Digital ID cards are commonly available, but rules vary by state—here’s what to know about electronic proof of insurance.

The Better Business Bureau profile for Encompass Insurance Company in Northbrook, Illinois shows no letter rating, no accreditation and zero complaints over the last three years, read on October 5, 2026. Read that as a thin record. Encompass policies are serviced inside Allstate, so complaints tend to land on Allstate’s profiles instead.

Advantages of Encompass Auto Insurance

  • Independent-agent support: Helpful for drivers who want a real person to explain coverages, adjust limits, or troubleshoot policy issues.
  • Strong bundling potential: Encompass is built for multi-policy households, and bundling is often where savings and simplicity show up the most (see how to bundle auto and homeowners insurance effectively).
  • Tier-based features: Options like accident forgiveness and enhanced replacement coverage may be available depending on your package level and eligibility.
  • Backed by a large carrier group: Encompass operates within the Allstate family of companies, which can matter for long-term stability and claims infrastructure.

Disadvantages of Encompass Auto Insurance

  • Not available everywhere: Product availability varies by state and can change over time.
  • Fewer “instant online” options: Many shoppers will need to contact an agent to quote, customize, and bind coverage.
  • Feature packaging can affect cost: If a feature you want is only included at a higher tier, you may pay more than with a carrier that sells add-ons à la carte.
  • Rideshare needs may require extra verification: Rideshare endorsements are not universally available across all insurers and states. If you drive for Uber or Lyft, ask specifically what coverage applies during each app period.

How To Get a Quote or File a Claim With Encompass

Quotes: Encompass is sold through independent agents. An agent can request quotes, apply discounts, and confirm whether optional coverages are available in your state. Encompass also lists 1-800-262-9262 on its contact page for anyone who wants to be put in touch with an Encompass independent agent.

Claims: Encompass typically accepts auto claims by phone. Its loss reporting line, which Encompass calls TimeSaver, is 1-800-588-7400. Encompass does not publish hours for it. Have your policy number, the date and time of loss, and any other driver and vehicle information ready.

Final Word – Encompass Review

Encompass is worth considering if you want agent guidance and you plan to bundle auto with home or other policies. It’s often a better fit for households that value coverage structure, service support, and add-on features over a purely DIY online buying process.

My advice is to ask the agent two questions before anything else: is Encompass writing new auto business in my state right now, and which Encompass company would issue the policy. If the answer to the first one is no, you have saved yourself an afternoon. Beyond that, compare coverage details as well as price. Get multiple quotes and review deductibles, liability limits, and optional protections to make sure you’re comparing like-for-like. You can also compare Encompass against other leading insurance providers to find the best match for your budget and needs.

Encompass contact basics: To report an auto claim, call 1-800-588-7400. To be put in touch with an agent, Encompass lists 1-800-262-9262. There is no Encompass customer service line. Policy changes go through the independent agent named on your policy documents and in your MyEncompass account, and billing and payments run through that account, so for billing use the number printed on your bill or ask your agent. Encompass publishes no hours for either phone line. Its address is 3100 Sanders Road, Northbrook, IL 60062, and Encompass says that address does not receive mail.

FAQs on Encompass Auto Insurance

Sources

Checked October 5, 2026