What Happens With Insurance If You Are At-Fault in an Accident?

Last Updated on October 14, 2026

If you’ve been involved in an at-fault collision, you can expect several consequences—including higher insurance premiums. Insurance companies rely heavily on your driving record when calculating your rates, and accident history is one of the most important factors they consider. Even a single at-fault accident can significantly impact what you pay.

Below, we explain what happens after an at-fault accident, how insurers determine fault, how much your rates may increase, and how long an at-fault crash stays on your record.

  • In LendingTree’s January 2026 study (a 30-year-old driver with a clean record and full coverage), a first at-fault accident raised rates about 45% on average. CarInsurance.com’s 2026 study uses a different sample driver, a 40-year-old, and shows about 61%. Your own increase depends on your insurer and state.
  • For CarInsurance.com’s 40-year-old sample driver, two at-fault accidents raised rates about 136% on average in its 2026 figures, and they may lead to non-renewal.
  • At-fault accidents usually stay on your driving record for 3–5 years, but serious incidents (like DUIs) can stay far longer.
  • The size of the increase varies widely by state. California and New Jersey had the biggest jumps in LendingTree’s January 2026 pricing.

What Happens After a Collision That’s Your Fault?

After an accident, your insurance company will investigate to determine who is at fault. This is true even if you think the situation is straightforward. Fault is determined based on evidence such as police reports, witness statements, traffic laws, and photos of the scene.

Examples:

  • Single-vehicle accidents: You’re almost always considered at fault.
  • Rear-end collisions: The rear driver is often—but not always—at fault.
  • Left-turn accidents: The turning driver is often—but not always—at fault.

In many cases, both drivers share some responsibility. At many insurers, and under some state rules, the driver found more than 50% responsible is labeled the “at-fault driver,” but the exact standard varies.

If you are found at fault, you will likely face increased insurance rates. If you are not at fault, your rates may not change at all—and in some states, it is illegal for insurers to raise your rates after a not-at-fault accident.

How Much Will Insurance Rates Rise After an At-Fault Collision?

An at-fault collision usually raises your insurance premium. The exact amount depends on the insurer, the state you live in, and the severity of the crash. Typically:

• First at-fault accident: LendingTree’s January 2026 pricing (a 30-year-old man with good credit, a clean record, full coverage and a 2018 Honda CR-V EX) showed an average 45% increase, about $1,031 a year. CarInsurance.com’s 2026 figures for a 40-year-old with full coverage on a Honda Accord LX, updated August 14, 2026, show about 61%. These are two separate studies with different sample drivers, so treat them as two examples, not one market average.

• With accident forgiveness: Your rate may not increase, but you could still lose good-driver discounts.

Minor accidents may barely affect your premium, while serious collisions with bodily injury claims can trigger steep surcharges.

After a Second At-Fault Collision, Rates Increase Even More

Insurers are generally lenient with your first at-fault accident, especially if your driving record was previously clean. But a second at-fault crash signals a pattern.

• Second at-fault accident: In the same CarInsurance.com study, two at-fault accidents raised its 40-year-old sample driver’s average premium about 136%, or $3,497 a year.

Two serious at-fault accidents may lead an insurer to label you a high-risk driver, making you subject to much higher premiums, or to non-renewal when the policy term ends.

Rate Increases Vary Between States and Insurers

Some states penalize drivers more harshly than others. Some insurers increase premiums aggressively; others raise them only slightly.

In LendingTree’s January 2026 pricing (a 30-year-old man with good credit, a clean record, full coverage and a 2018 Honda CR-V EX):

  • California drivers saw the biggest average increase, 70.7%, after one at-fault accident.
  • New Jersey was next at 62.7%.
  • Pennsylvania drivers saw the smallest increase, 16.5% on average.

Pennsylvania was the only state below 20%. New York (22.4%), Wyoming (31.7%), Michigan (31.8%) and Rhode Island (33.8%) also came in well under the national average.

The steepest increases, all 54% or more, were in California, New Jersey, New Hampshire, Maryland, Connecticut, Nevada, Minnesota, Arizona, Maine and Massachusetts. Other companies and other driver profiles will give different numbers, so use these as a guide to how your state compares.

Rate increase after one at-fault accident by state (LendingTree, January 2026 pricing):

StateAverage Annual Premium (Full Coverage)Premium After One At-Fault AccidentPercent Increase
California$2,383$4,06770.7%
New Jersey$3,188$5,18862.7%
New Hampshire$1,531$2,45760.5%
Maryland$2,536$4,06560.3%
Connecticut$2,712$4,23856.3%
Nevada$2,783$4,33555.8%
Minnesota$2,256$3,51455.7%
Arizona$3,820$5,91154.8%
Maine$1,246$1,92154.3%
Massachusetts$1,710$2,63854.2%
Idaho$1,630$2,51154.0%
Illinois$2,115$3,24753.6%
South Dakota$1,998$3,04952.6%
Utah$2,220$3,38552.5%
Kentucky$2,238$3,40552.2%
Missouri$2,559$3,84450.2%
Wisconsin$1,867$2,76147.9%
Mississippi$2,107$3,11447.8%
Oregon$2,146$3,16547.4%
Louisiana$4,006$5,88146.8%
Indiana$1,704$2,49846.6%
Georgia$2,696$3,94746.4%
Florida$3,411$4,98346.1%
Texas$2,636$3,85246.1%
Vermont$1,345$1,95945.6%
Alaska$1,862$2,69744.8%
Ohio$1,678$2,42144.3%
Kansas$2,391$3,41943.0%
Arkansas$2,772$3,95342.6%
Colorado$3,289$4,68642.5%
DC$2,886$4,08441.5%
Alabama$2,117$2,99441.4%
Oklahoma$2,285$3,23141.4%
North Carolina$1,212$1,71141.2%
Iowa$2,016$2,84241.0%
Nebraska$2,251$3,16940.8%
New Mexico$2,363$3,32840.8%
Montana$2,366$3,27638.5%
North Dakota$1,944$2,68738.2%
South Carolina$1,947$2,67237.3%
Washington$2,616$3,58737.1%
West Virginia$1,706$2,33937.1%
Hawaii$1,563$2,13436.6%
Tennessee$1,943$2,65536.6%
Delaware$2,946$4,02136.5%
Virginia$1,718$2,33535.9%
Rhode Island$2,898$3,87833.8%
Michigan$2,461$3,24331.8%
Wyoming$1,323$1,74231.7%
New York$2,610$3,19322.4%
Pennsylvania$2,130$2,48116.5%

How Long Does an At-Fault Collision Stay on Your Record?

An at-fault collision typically stays on your driving record for 3 to 5 years. However, the timeline varies by state and by the severity of the incident.

Examples:

  • California: Accidents and most violations stay on the record the DMV reports for 3 years, some two-point violations for 7 years, and DUI convictions for 10 years.
  • Florida: DUI convictions stay on your driving record far longer than an ordinary crash, often cited as decades. Ask the Florida DHSMV what your record shows.

As your record ages and you drive without additional incidents, your premiums will gradually decrease again. Once the accident is past your insurer’s lookback period, it should stop counting in your rate, though your premium can still change for other reasons.

My advice is to report the crash to your insurer and follow your state’s crash-reporting rules, then ask your agent how long the claim will count against you and whether you have accident forgiveness. At renewal, get two or three quotes at the same limits, because some companies surcharge a first accident much less than others.

FAQs

Final Word on At-Fault Accidents and Insurance

Your driving record is one of the biggest factors insurers use to calculate premiums. In LendingTree’s January 2026 study, a single at-fault collision raised its sample driver’s full-coverage rate by about 45% on average, and an accident may stay on your record for years.

If the accident involved a DUI or caused severe injury, the impact on your premiums may last even longer. Avoid additional violations, compare quotes regularly, and practice safe driving to reduce the long-term financial impact.

Sources

Checked October 13, 2026